License plate readers, Article I, Section 23, and a question Florida answered in 19891
Most lawyers get them: the questions from friends and family at the weekend backyard barbecue, asking us to weigh in on whatever story is making headlines. Lately I’m getting a lot of questions about the license plate cameras that have been in the news. “Don’t they violate the constitution?” they ask. Summoning pretty much every lawyer’s favorite two words, I respond: “It depends. Which constitution are we talking about?”
No Florida court that I am aware of has answered the specific question, so what follows is how I answer it when I’m grilling and chilling.
What Are We Actually Talking About?
The cameras in question are automated license plate readers, or ALPRs. They photograph every vehicle that passes, logging not only the plate number but also the vehicle type, make, color, plate state, missing or covered plates, bumper stickers, decals, roof racks, and even the number of times the vehicle has been seen. The industry markets the result as a “vehicle fingerprint.” A single camera can read plates up to a hundred feet away across two lanes of traffic, and one vendor claims a 97% capture rate. Each image and its metadata go into a searchable database. Cameras can be installed publicly along roadways or privately by shopping centers, businesses, and HOAs, and subscribers can query data from any camera whose owner has opted into sharing. The networks are enormous; one vendor reports more than 120,000 cameras across 49 states.
These systems have real investigative value. They recover stolen vehicles and help locate missing people. But my barbecue friends aren’t asking me to rank their usefulness. They’re asking me if the cameras pass muster.2 The constitutional question is narrower: what, if anything, must (or should) the government show before querying the compiled record of where (and when)3 a particular car has been?
The Constitution Everyone Reaches For
The instinct is to look to the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, and for good reason. In Carpenter v. United States, the Supreme Court held that obtaining 127 days of cell-site records was a search, rejecting the argument that public exposure forfeits the privacy interest. In June 2026, the Court went further in Chatrie v. United States, holding that obtaining location data through a geofence warrant is a search notwithstanding the third-party doctrine, and rejecting the argument that a narrow slice of an enormous database is a smaller intrusion.
But the Fourth Amendment has limits. It reaches only government conduct, so a camera an HOA or shopping center installs on its own property sits outside it entirely. Its remedy is suppression of evidence, which requires a prosecution, and a driver who is never charged has nothing to suppress. And Article I, Section 12 of our own constitution is no help: a conformity clause added by the voters in 1982 binds Florida courts to federal doctrine and forbids going further (see Perez v. State, 620 So. 2d 1256, 1258 (Fla. 1993); Bernie v. State, 524 So. 2d 988, 992 (Fla. 1988)). So in Florida, unless you’re charged with a crime, the Fourth Amendment doesn’t give you much to work with when it comes to ALPRs.
The Constitution in Our Own Backyard
Article I, Section 23 of the Florida Constitution guarantees that “[e]very natural person has the right to be let alone and free from governmental intrusion into the person’s private life.” It stands on its own. Its drafters deliberately omitted words like “unreasonable” and “unwarranted” to make it as strong as possible, and it carries no conformity clause (Winfield v. Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering, 477 So. 2d 544, 548 (Fla. 1985)). Once it attaches, the State must show a compelling interest pursued through the least intrusive means (id. at 547). It also isn’t confined to criminal cases. Declaratory and injunctive relief are ordinary Section 23 remedies, so the driver who is never charged still has something to point to (see, e.g., Rasmussen v. South Florida Blood Service, Inc., 500 So. 2d 533 (Fla. 1987) (applying Section 23 to civil discovery)).
And we have a case on point that is 37 years old. In Shaktman v. State, 553 So. 2d 148, 151 (Fla. 1989), the Florida Supreme Court held that Section 23 is implicated when the government gathers telephone numbers through a pen register. That was ten years after the U.S. Supreme Court found no Fourth Amendment interest in the identical information in Smith v. Maryland. The Shaktman Court rejected the third-party doctrine outright, holding that the caller’s expectation “is not defeated by the fact that the telephone company has that information,” and agreeing with the Colorado Supreme Court that it “is somewhat idle to speak of assuming risks” where a phone subscriber “has no realistic alternative” (Shaktman, 553 So. 2d at 151 (quoting People v. Sporleder, 666 P.2d 135, 141 (Colo. 1983))). That was 1989. It’s now 2026, and nobody has a realistic alternative to driving on a road.
Shaktman also tells us what Section 23 demands once it attaches: procedural safeguards that “at a minimum, necessitate judicial approval prior to the state’s intrusion into a person’s privacy,” a reasonable founded suspicion of criminal use, and a “clear connection between the illegal activity and the person whose privacy would be invaded” (id. at 152). Measure a plate query against those requirements and it satisfies none of the three. No judge approves the query beforehand. No founded suspicion predicates it. And no investigation connects the government to the drivers whose movements were recorded long before anyone suspected anyone of anything. Section 23 has simply never been pointed at them.
Two Objections, and One More
The first objection: how can the constitution be stood up against a private camera vendor? It doesn’t have to be. The constitutional pressure falls on the government’s use of the data, and that works the same way whoever owns the camera. If a shopping center or HOA owns it, the private party’s capture sits outside the constitution, but the moment law enforcement queries that vendor’s database, the government is the one intruding, and Section 23 applies. If the city or the sheriff owns the camera, the case is even more direct. The government is both collecting and searching, so every step of the process is state action, and a challenger can argue that Section 23 is implicated at capture and retention, not just at the query. Either way, the query is the one hook that works for every camera, and it’s where I would focus first.
The second: wouldn’t a warrant requirement hamstring genuine emergencies? Carpenter answers that, preserving exigent circumstances in the same opinion that required the warrant (585 U.S. at 330, recognizing pursuit of a fleeing suspect, protection of individuals threatened with imminent harm, and prevention of imminent destruction of evidence). The stolen car is covered, and so is an AMBER or Silver Alert.
And then there’s the one I hear most: “If you aren’t doing anything wrong, why should you care?” Ask Chrisanna Elser. A plate reader caught her green Rivian passing through a small Colorado town near the time a $25 package vanished from a porch, and a police sergeant came to her door with a petty theft summons. He offered, as though it were itself incriminating, that the database showed her driving through the town twenty times that month. It took her own dashcam footage, a Google Maps log, and two weeks to get the summons voided.4 Thanks to the cameras, Ms. Elser had to prove her innocence when the only “evidence” against her was a compiled record of otherwise lawful behavior.
Back to the Barbecue
This is a live question, and it is moving quickly. Vendors have begun tightening their own controls. FDOT recently revoked permits for readers within state highway rights-of-way, which leaves cameras on municipal streets, county roads, and private property untouched. Importantly, those permits were revoked voluntarily and unilaterally by the same agency that issued them in the first place. The cameras came down by memorandum and so could go back up just as easily.
In 1980, Florida’s voters wrote a privacy right into our constitution that most states do not have, and in 1989 our Supreme Court explained how it works when the government compiles a record of your otherwise innocent activity. Does it apply to ALPRs? Nobody has asked a court yet. Until someone does, the best current answer is the one I give at the cookout: it depends. And once I explain why, I ask which constitution they’d want to reach for when the cameras are pointed at them. It’s usually the one in our own backyard.
- A version of this blog post appeared as an article in the October, 2026 issue of the Inter Alia, the newsletter of the Manatee County Bar Association. ↩︎
- Being at a barbecue, I tried hard to write a “pass the mustard” joke out of “pass muster,” but I couldn’t land it. So I’ll drop it here. You’re welcome. ↩︎
- A “where” without a “when” proves nothing, and the reverse proves less. Hermann Minkowski illustrated the point in 1908, explaining that locating an event takes four coordinates (three of space, one of time) and giving the path an object traces through them a name: its “worldline.” Hermann Minkowski, Raum und Zeit (Cologne, Sept. 21, 1908), translated here. See also StarTalk, Neil deGrasse Tyson Explains Worldlines, YouTube (Mar. 29, 2022). An ALPR does not photograph a place. It records an event, and enough events, indexed and searchable, document the worldline of whatever vehicle is being queried. ↩︎
- The summons was voided on October 15, 2025, and the officer was subsequently disciplined. See The Colorado Sun (Nov. 11, 2025). ↩︎






